Diskite:IMMAGINE&POESIA: Diferans ant vèsyon yo
Contenu supprimé Contenu ajouté
Aucun résumé des modifications |
|||
Liy 33 :
::{{Reponn|Oberon12|Orland|WhisperToMe|WhatamIdoing}} I find the [[Espesyal:Diff/689970|four recently added references]] problematic: (i) 2084‑1124 is a proper ISSN, but it’s for a blog<ref>http://worldcat.org/issn/2084-1124</ref> (ii) ''The Seventh Quarry'' is a magazine, but it doesn’t seem to review poetry as Oberon12 indicated twice<ref>“[[Espesyal:Diff/689969|articles from '''poetry reviews''' of different countries have been added]]”</ref><ref>“[[Espesyal:Diff/689971|independent secondary sources have been recently added ('''poetry reviews''' from different countries)]]”</ref> — even in cases where the poets are featured<ref>http://rua.ua.es/dspace/bitstream/10045/53707/1/2015_Gaspar-Jaen_The-Seventh-Quarry.pdf or https://imgur.com/mmvbs2v</ref> (iii) I am unable to verify the content of any of these new references as they are cited (iv) I am also unable to verify that the articles as they are cited even exist. Finally, this many [[:en:Red flag (idiom)|red flags]] from a single edit, is itself, another red flag. Thank you. —<span style="text-shadow:0 0 .15em #900">[[Itilizatè:LLarson|LLarson]]</span> <small>([[Diskisyon Itilizatè:LLarson|di]] & [[Espesyal:Kontribisyon/LLarson|fè]])</small> 17 mas 2016 à 19:31 (UTC)
:::Do those refs actually mention this group by name, and say something about the group that exceeds merely "This poet belongs to (or founded) this group"? [[Itilizatè:WhatamIdoing|WhatamIdoing]] ([[Diskisyon Itilizatè:WhatamIdoing|discussion]]) 18 mas 2016 à 21:27 (UTC)
:{{Reponn|WhatamIdoing}} {{Reponn|LLarson}} I have added a reference of the Art Review on ArtSlant re what the Movement is and what it does [http://www.artslant.com/ew/articles/show/43297].
All the references added mention "Immagine & Poesia" as an art literary movement.''The Seventh Quarry" is a poetry review published in Wales: since 2014 it has published articles re the Movement once a year (of course not the issue referring to 6 Catalan poets posted by someone). ''Krytyca Literacka'' is above all a paper poetry review published in Poland. There is a book published in NY [http://www.amazon.it/Immagine-Poesia-The-Movement-Progress/dp/0893049948]. I don't think that all the articles on Wikipedia have more references than these. Let me know please what else is needed. Thanks--[[Itilizatè:Oberon12|Oberon12]] ([[Diskisyon Itilizatè:Oberon12|discussion]]) 22 mas 2016 à 14:10 (UTC)
| |||